Them Dems

archived: 30 Mar - 5 Apr, 2008         Back                 Next

UPDATED:  APR 3, 2008

                        RATING THE HOUSE 

The Cook Political Report rates the US House races.  Cook finds that 80 House seats are generally in play; 44 Republican districts and 36 Democratic districts.   

Cook rates 2 Democratic (highlighted in blue) seats and 11 Republican seats (highlighted in red) as toss ups.  They are:                

OR-05 OPEN (Hooley) D+1
AL-05 OPEN (Cramer) R+6

AZ-01 OPEN (Renzi) R+2
LA-06 VACANT (Baker) R+7
MN-03 OPEN (Ramstad) R+1
NJ-03 OPEN (Saxton) D+3
NJ-07 OPEN (Ferguson) R+1
NM-01 OPEN (Wilson) D+2
NY-25 OPEN (Walsh) D+3
NY-26 OPEN (Reynolds) R+3
OH-15 OPEN (Pryce) R+1
OH-16 OPEN (Regula) R+4
VA-11 OPEN (Davis) R+1
     

Cook rates 15 Democratic seats has leaning Democratic (highlighted in blue) and one Republican seat leaning Democratic (highlighted in red and underlined).  They are: 

AZ-05 Harry Mitchell R+4
AZ-08 Gabrielle Giffords R+1
CA-11 Jerry McNerney R+3
FL-16 Tim Mahoney R+2
GA-08 Jim Marshall R+8

IL-11 OPEN (Weller) R+1

IL-14 Bill Foster R+5
IN-09 Baron Hill R+7
KS-02 Nancy Boyda R+7
NH-01 Carol Shea-Porter D+0
NY-20 Kirsten Gillibrand R+3
PA-04 Jason Altmire R+3
PA-10 Chris Carney R+8
TX-22 Nick Lampson R+15
WI-08 Steve Kagen R+4  

Thirteen additional Republican seats are rated as leaning Republican (highlighted in red).  They are: 

AL-02 OPEN (Everett) R+13
AK-AL Don Young*# R+14
CO-04 Marilyn Musgrave R+9
CT--04 Christopher Shays D+5
IL-10 Mark Kirk D+4
LA-04 OPEN (McCrery) R+7
MI-07 Tim Walberg R+2
NV-03 Jon Porter D+1
NY-29 Randy Kuhl R+5
NC-08 Robin Hayes R+3
OH-01 Steve Chabot R+1
OH-02 Jean Schmidt R+13
WA-08 Dave Reichert D+2
 

The toss up and lean districts will be, in Cook’s estimation, the most competitive in the United States.  Geographically, the competitive districts involve 27 States (first column) with only eight States having multiple districts in play (highlighted in blue, underlined): 

AK-1

NC-1

AL-2

NH-1

AZ-3

NJ-2

CA-1

NM-1

CO-1

NV-1

CT-1

NY-4

FL-1

OH-4

GA-1

OR-1

IL-3

PA-2

IN-1

TX-1

KS-1

VA-1

LA-2

WA-1

MI-1

WI-1

MN-1

 

Cook has also identified 19 Democratic and 11 Republican districts that may also come into play.  Click here for a review of those seats.

In total, Cook envisions only one race, IL-11 OPEN (Weller) R+1, in which Democrats are favored to pick up a Republican seat.  The remaining highly competitive seats will be essentially be hard fought contests for the Democratic Party, both to defend vulnerable seats and pick up Republican seats.

_____________________________________________

UPDATED:  MAR 30, 2008

                        CONSIDER 

Sen. Obama supporters demand that Sen. Clinton quit.  Sen. Clinton promises to remain in the race.  Supporters of both candidates are spewing out hyperbolic attacks.  Many Democrats, including TPJ, are worried that the obvious split in the Democratic Party threatens victory for either candidate.   

Larry Sabato makes the case for why Sen. Clinton’s continuing candidacy is ultimately a benefit to Sen. Obama should he win the nomination.  His perspectives deserve serious consideration: 

Meanwhile, Obama has suffered through a couple of his worst political weeks ever, and the national polls and the Pennsylvania surveys are reflecting that. The cumulative effect of Rev. Wright's outrageous and incendiary babblings, Michelle Obama's statement about lack of previous pride in America, and Barack Obama's past refusal to wear an American flag pin on his lapel or to place hand-over-heart during the national anthem are yielding the expected whisper campaign: He's unpatriotic. In American politics, patriotism has often been the first, not the last, refuge of scoundrels. Legitimate criticism can be leveled at Obama for meekly sitting through Wright's tirades for years, but stretching this transgression into anti-Americanism and disloyalty is out of bounds. It's no better than the persistent, utterly false emails we all receive that breathlessly announce Obama is, in fact, a Muslim Manchurian candidate. (For the record, for the millionth time, Obama is a Christian.)  

To round out the roster of debatable criticisms, let's turn to Hillary Clinton. The chorus urging her withdrawal from the Democratic contest has begun to be heard, from Obama-endorsing Gov. Bill Richardson, the Obama-tilting cable channel MSNBC, and various columnists and commentators who have leaned Obama's way for some time. She is "dividing the party" and "raising issues that could hurt Obama in the fall," the detractors say.  

First of all, while now undeniably the underdog, Clinton still has some measurable chance (20-25 percent) to be the nominee if some substantial breaks fall her way. She seems headed for a sizeable victory in Pennsylvania, the largest state still on the primary schedule, and wins in several other places, such as Kentucky, West Virginia, and the commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Clinton has come reasonably close to splitting the popular vote and delegates, and her constituency groups (women, seniors, blue collars, Hispanics) are among the essential elements of a Democratic victory in November. Moreover, no one knows the future, no one knows what controversies or gaffes or scandals might arise to change the current equation. A candidate who has sacrificed much to get to the finals has every right to continue fighting as long as a triumph is reasonably conceivable.  

Finally, one of the purposes of a nominating contest is to test the candidates, uncover their weaknesses, and harden them for the tougher fall campaign to come. Should he be the nominee, Obama will be a better one for the trial of fire he has endured from some of the political world's best, nestled in the Clinton camp. Reaching the winner's circle after the longest marathon in modern American presidential politics could be part of Obama's answer to the charge of inexperience. Now, tell us again why Hillary should withdraw?

                        RATING THE SENATE

TPJ has a great deal of respect for Cook Political Report.  They are generally guarded in their predictions and more often right than wrong.   

While the Democratic Presidential primary is “sucking all of the oxygen out of the room” in the press, Cook recently rated the US Senate races.  It presents a fascinating early assessment of the Democratic Party’s drive to win 60 seats (filibuster proof).  

Cook envisions: 

One Democratic seat is in jeopardy:  Landrieu (LA).
            One Republican seat will probably go Democratic: VA (Warner)
            Five Republican seats are Toss Ups: Stevens (AK), CO (Allard), Coleman (MN), Sununu (NH) and NM (Domenici)
            Two Republican seats bear watching: Collins (ME) and Smith (OR) 

Even if Sen. Landrieu holds her seat and Democrats win all eight Republican races; certainly not an assured result, Democrats will still not have the 60 seats they need as Sen. Lieberman is obviously an unreliable vote.  All of which points to the necessity of Democrats winning the Presidency in ’08.   

                        TESTING BOTTOM 

TPJ has been following the suspected deterioration of Bush’s approval rating.  In our last analysis, we thought two more polls were necessary to confirm the apparent trend – one new poll has just been released – Pew.  Pew pegs Bush’s approval rating at 28%, the second poll this month below 30%.   

Democrats should remain skeptical however.  Carefully note that of five polls (highlighted in blue) with Bush at 30% approval or less, four of those five polls find a rather high number of Americans with no opinion (highlighted in red).   Of the remaining polls with generally lower number of “no opinion,” Bush’s approval is a point or two higher. 

The shift from approval to no opinion is a phenomenon that previously occurred during Bush’s low point in Spring 2007.  There is a logical explanation that may explain the phenomenon.  At a 30% approval rating, Bush is starting to lose some of his Republican base.  One would expect that Republicans who have loyally supported Bush would a) only reluctantly withdraw their support and b) would be less inclined to express disapproval in contrast with simply withholding an opinion.  

Each new poll suggests the drop in “approval” rating is real.  However, TPJ does not generally believe a trend absent 10 polls confirming the trend.  One more poll is needed.  

IF the trend is real, Bush’s approval rating is threatening to break through the psychological barrier of 30%.  It will generate a plethora of articles about Bush being the most unpopular President in history – certainly not a selling point for the Republicans.   

TPJ'S BUSH WATCH

 

 

Approve

Trail Mo

Disapprove

No Opinion

Spread

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2008

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pew

3/19-22/08

28

 

63

9

-35

FOX/Opinion Dynamics

3/18-19/08

30

 

60

10

-30

CBS

3/15-18/08

29

 

64

7

-35

CNN/Opinion Research

3/14-16/08

31

 

67

1

-36

USA Today/Gallup

3/14-16/08

32

 

64

4

-32

NBC/Wall Street Journal

3/7-10/08

32

 

63

5

-31

Newsweek

3/5-6/08

30

 

61

9

-31

AP-Ipsos

3/3-5/08

30

 

66

4

-36

ABC/Washington Post

2/28 - 3/2/08

32

 

66

2

-34

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

March Avg

30.44

-2.11

63.78

5.67

-33.33

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

February Avg

32.56

0.22

62.56

4.67

-30.00

 

January Avg

32.33

-1.12

63.13

4.47

-30.80

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2007

 

 

 

 

 

 

December Avg

33.45

0.85

61.82

4.45

-28.36

 

November Avg

32.60

-0.50

61.81

5.59

-29.21

 

October Avg

33.10

-0.07

60.90

5.90

-27.80

 

September Avg

33.17

1.17

61.75

5.17

-28.58

 

August Avg

32.00

1.58

61.67

6.33

-29.33

 

July Avg

30.42

-0.43

63.50

6.08

-33.08

 

June Avg

30.85

-2.38

63.23

6.00

-32.38

 

May Avg

33.22

-1.70

61.33

5.56

-28.11

 

April Avg

34.92

1.49

59.92

5.15

-25.00

 

March Avg

33.43

-0.24

60.43

6.14

-27.00

 

February Avg

33.67

-0.22

60.17

6.08

-26.50

 

January Avg

33.89

-1.61

61.61

4.83

-27.70